Saturday, March 20, 2010

Realities & Dreams

Realities & Dreams

Many novels use contrasting places to represent opposing ideas. Steinbeck plays out this technique in his novel, Of Mice and Men. The two places in the book are first, the ranch Lennie and George work at and their dream house they want to buy and live in after they gather enough money. The ranch represents the harsh reality and the sad futures of workers. The house represents dream and hope, it is also what motivates George and Lennie to work hard and save money. And through these two places, Steinbeck shows how important companionship is in a lonely world.
The book takes place near Salinas, California around the mid-1800s. George and Lennie like many other working men at the time move around ranches and work until they earn their money and wander about. However, unlike George and Lennie many of these men spend money on drinks and women becaues they know that they can never elevate themselves up. When George and Lennie arrive to the new ranch, the conditions are not good. The boss's son gives Lennie a hard time and George has a hard time looking after Lennie. Lennie asks George numerous times while at the ranch when they can leave. He complains how he cannot stand the horrible place. There are only men at the ranch, the only woman is Curley's wife, who is the wife of the boss's son. All of the men here are hopeless -they adjusted their lives and needs just enough to live and work. There is no real friendliness, everyone keeps their guards up and do what they are supposed to do. When Lennie gets upset, George starts talking about their future dream house -a place where there's a warm oven, alfalfa patches, rabbits running around, chickens and cows to raise, a place where they would have their independence and freedom and do whatever, whenever they want to. The more Lennie and George talk about it, the more real the dream becomes. The dream house not only appeals to George and Lennie but one of the old workers, Candy is infatuated by their goal and joins in. He too wants a place to stay to spend the rest of his life. The dream then becomes more realistic with Candy's help from all the money he saved up.
These two contrasting places contribute to Of Mice and Men by showing the importance of companionship in a lonely world. George knows that it is Lennie that makes him believe that they could buy the house more. It is Lennie's naivete and his support that further drives George. Candy, too, who used to be independent and distant as the other men, becomes close with George and Lennie when he joins in the plan. The more real the dream house becomes, the less real the ranch becomes. However, when Lennie dies at the end of the book, George and Candy give up on all their plans and faces 'reality.' George states that he knew that it wasn't a realistic goal but that Lennie made it seem real. Therefore, Steinbeck reinforces the fact how harmful loneliness can be, it is only companionship that made George and Lennie's dream more real than the harsh reality they live in.

8 comments:

  1. I really liked your essay overall :) It put the entire "Of Mice and Men" book into perspective for me, since I didn't really know what the point of the book was. You did a good job summarizing the book too, and explaining the actions and meanings of the characters as well.

    I only suggest relating the essay more to the locations than the characters. Other than that it was a refreshing take on the book ^^

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ohh, I liked this book! :)
    Very good job. I think that from the very first paragraph it was clear what you were comparing.
    Like Farah said, there was a lot about the characters so maybe focusing more on the locations would enhance the writing more :)
    Very good job!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Wow! that was a good essay, and it was verrry insightful!
    I really like how you used their imaginary dream place as the second contrasting place - I wouldn't have thought to use a dream as a second opposing place which I think is the most interesting aspect of this essay.
    Other than a few grammatical errors (which were practically unnoticeable - i only noticed since i read your essay like five times XP) the essay was really good. it was to the point and it brought up interesting supporting details that helped your argument.
    Great job(:

    ReplyDelete
  4. I loved this book! Your essay was well written. But it looks like one huge paragraph because you didn't put any spaces in between each one =P. I liked how you mentioned a few times how effective loneliness can be, and then had the conclusion strongly state the message of the story once more.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I love this book haha. And like Ari said, using their dream house was very innovative and pretty genius haha.
    Your word choice and overall all writing worked perfectly together and it is a very good essay.
    :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Your essay was very well organized and the locations you chose were unexpected, which I liked. I agree with everyone else's comments, focus a little bit more on the characteristics of the locations themselves, like what the alfalfa patches and rabbits symbolize I guess.
    Besides that, I loved the intro, it was very easy to read and refreshed my memory of the story without summarizing the whole thing for me ;)

    ReplyDelete
  7. i liked your essay grace (: especially the fact that you started off with the differences between the ranch and the house then explained the companionship and loneliness. really great diction and overall good job :D

    ReplyDelete
  8. grace,
    this was a pleasure to read because I love this book so very much. I think it was an excellent choice to use this book to compare places. I think you did a good job explaing companionship between lennie and george. i thought you did well showing the difference between their dream home on the farm and their home in real life. you also gave a good background of the book so it helped me connect it all together. :) I think maybe you could elaborate a little more on the differences between their fantacy home and the reality they live in now. wonderful job grace!

    -dani

    ReplyDelete